International students can continue to rely on duration of status, and elective internships taken for academic credit can still qualify for Curricular Practical Training (CPT). Two judges in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts reached those results in separate cases. On November 16, the court struck down the Department of Homeland Security’s fixed-admission rule after deciding the merits. On November 17, the court temporarily blocked two federal messages that narrowed CPT eligibility.
The court vacates DHS’s F-1 student fixed-admission rule
In Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. DHS, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs and set aside the entire rule under the Administrative Procedure Act. A September 14 order had already prevented the rule from taking effect the next day. DHS argued that fixed admission periods would improve oversight and address fraud and national security risks. The court found that DHS had inadequately weighed costs and benefits, failed to substantiate its reasons for the change, overlooked less burdensome alternatives, and inadequately addressed significant public comments.
Under duration of status, or D/S, an F‑1 student’s authorized stay generally follows their course of study and any authorized practical training, provided they maintain F‑1 status. The vacated rule would have replaced duration of status for F‑1 students with a fixed admission period tied to their program length and capped at four years. Students would generally have had to apply to USCIS for an extension to finish a longer program or pursue post-completion OPT or STEM OPT. The rule also would have shortened the standard grace period from 60 to 30 days, restricted school transfers and changes in majors or degree levels, and capped standalone English-language training at 24 months.
The court temporarily blocks both CPT messages
In Association of American Universities v. DHS, Judge Julia E. Kobick stayed both Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP) messages nationwide pending judicial review. A separate preliminary injunction protects the plaintiff associations and their members, including member institutions’ employees and students, against enforcement of the messages’ interpretation. That protection covers future conduct as well as conduct and approvals that predated the messages.
For decades, federal guidance allowed schools to authorize elective training for academic credit as CPT when it was part of an established curriculum and met the other requirements. The two messages would have narrowed that policy in distinct ways by requiring DSOs to only authorize CPT employment "if its absence would make the attainment of a degree an impossibility." The broadcast also mandates that the work associated with the CPT must be "required for all students pursuing that degree".
Judge Kobick found that the messages were reviewable agency action and that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their claim that SEVP had changed its longstanding position without acknowledging or explaining the change or considering how schools and students had relied on it. The order provides interim relief while the litigation continues.
What this means for F‑1 students now
The DHS may decide to appeal these decision. But as of now, duration of status remains in effect nationwide. A for-credit elective internship, co-op, or practicum can still qualify for CPT if it is part of the established curriculum, directly related to the student’s major, and meets the other eligibility requirements. Students whose school denied or withdrew CPT approval should ask their DSO to review the placement and confirm authorization before they start or resume work.